Jay Vs. Jack: Top Ten Favorite Bands

[elias]

Voted for Jack - props for having Queen in there.

My top 10:

Pixies
The White Stripes
Kings of Leon
The Pogues
The Specials
The Clash/ Big Audio Dynamite
Led Zeppelin
The Libertines
New Order/ Joy Division
)EIB( [Bad Company UK]

[Uncle Igmar]

Great job guys - some of Jay's picks were cool - even some of them new-fangled bands - but I had to go with Jack - could be the age thing - since we are the same age and I hate cell phones too.

Anyway - here are my Top 11 - just couldn't throw out the 11th - in no particular order - I love them all - but if I had to pick a Number 1 - it would be RUSH.

The Doors - "The End" - "Roadhouse Blues"
Creedance Clearwater Revival - "Bad Moon Rising"
Queen - "Death on Two Legs" - "'39" - "Bohemian Rhapsody"
Aerosmith - "Train Kept Arollin" - "Janie's Got a Gun" - "Sweet Emotion"
RUSH - "YYZ" - "Closer to the Heart" - "Rhythm Method"
Genesis - "Home By The Sea" - "The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway"
Chicago - "25 or 6 to 4" - "Saturday in the Park"
Pink Floyd - "Brain Damage/Eclipse" - "Comfortably Numb" - "Run Like Hell"
The Police - "Synchronicity Part 2" - "Roxanne"
The Eagles - "Hotel California" - "Pretty Maids All in a Row" - "Lyin' Eyes"
Lynyrd Skynyrd - "Free Bird" - "Gimme 3 Steps"

There Ya Go

[Steve]

I had to pick Jay's, I just like some of his better.

my top ten:

10. Radiohead
9. Rush
8. AIR
7. Daft Punk
6. The Beatles
5. Sublime
4. Manu Chao
3. Rage Against the Machine
2. Nine Inch Nails
1. Guns N' Roses

[monsterjester]

Had to go with Jay on this one; here's my list:
10. Pink Floyd
9. The Beatles
8. Pearl Jam
7. Red Hot Chili Peppers
6. Queens of the Stone Age
5. The Strokes
4. The White Stripes
3. Stone Temple Pilots
2. Sublime
1. Nirvana
Hey, what do you want, I'm a product of my generation.

[polyesterpants]

There's no other choice but Jay as the winner. Jack had the Fab Four and that's about it. When you got Jay throwing down with At The Drive In, Radiohead, The Mars Volta, and out of nowhere Faith No Fricken More!! You don't have a chance.

My top 5

1. Pearl Jam
2. Radiohead
3. Beck
4. Sigur Ros
5. The White Stripes

Luke

[Susi]

I'm coming from the same generation as Jay, but I just gotta go with Jack's top ten on this one.

[vicious590]

good choice JACK WOOT!

[Denver the Last Dinosaur]

Sorry Jay, and sorry for the pun, but Jack, you had me at ELO.

Man that was a bad one ;D (if you don't get it... think Jerry Maguire ) Here is my list:

10. Evanescence
9. Pink Floyd
8. Genesis
7. Queen
6. Dire Straits
5. R.E.M
4. Guillemots
3. Gorrilaz
2. Arctic Monkeys
1. Nickleback

The dinosaur song is STILL in my head by the way

[orchid]

Definitely a tough choice, but I vote for Jack.

+1 for gabrielsangel I agree, Queen is my number one favorite too!

[Redsox]

my top 5

5: the band -no explanation NESSASARY
4: angels and airwaves -one album fantastic perhaps the best since early u2
3:u2- fantastic bono for me is u2 even thow the edge is great u2 would work if anyone else sang thats why u2 cover songs normally stink.
2:coldplay- so good every song is great a great album band
1- DAVE MATTHEWS BAND - great songwriting by every member of the band also they never play anything the same great improv. if you think that dmb is diffined by crash into me that you hear on the radio i incurage you to check out a live show there all free just get a torrent

[Colleen]

Wow, who would have thought that the fate of a RambleCast vote would ride so heavily on a little queen?

[Norton]

Now c'mon let's be nice...he's at least 5'6" right?

[Steve]

I may be the only person in the world who hates Queen....

[Redsox]

no no your not i proudly stand up with you

[Colleen]

norton said:

Now c'mon let's be nice...he's at least 5'6" right?

Whoosh! Joke goes way over your head