Who is the 50% candidate

[markedman]

This is built on so many "ifs" it doesn't rise to a theory so I put it here:-)

• If certain people are right that Jacob and MIB are the same person, and
  
• If he somehow split himself into two pieces, and
  
• If those pieces are perfectly balanced as represented by the rocks and scales, then...
  

... perhaps the ultimate candidate is the one evenly divided between good and evil (assuming that's the metric). If so, I would vote for Jack or Kate. They may be boneheads, but they're 50/50 boneheads.

[spinaltumor]

Ew, Kate.

I think Sawyer's pretty 50/50.

[julerfan]

I would say Hurley, he's good at heart but will do bad if his friends are in trouble.