help with kate | The Lost Podcast Listener Forum

tomfromminnesota
Full Member

Posts: 156

help with kate Jul 25, 2009 0:06:06 GMT -5

Quote

Post by tomfromminnesota on Jul 25, 2009 0:06:06 GMT -5

hi all

Been awhile, but am rewatching first couple of seasons and something just keeps bothering me about Kate, or at least one scene in particular: in All the best cowboys ... when Jack's attempting to revive Charlie, what gives with her telling Jack, a surgeon, to quit???

Locke--Hey, is he talking about what I think he was talking about?

Ben--If you mean time traveling bunnies, then, yes.

Locke--You do know that he said specifically not to put anything metal in there?

spinaltumor
God

*jears*

Posts: 2,571

help with kate Jul 25, 2009 17:39:44 GMT -5

Quote

Post by spinaltumor on Jul 25, 2009 17:39:44 GMT -5

Because Kate sucks.

Haha, noo, noo....

I just think it doesn't take long after one meets Jack to realize he's very Mr. Fix-it and tends not to like giving up. Charlie looked very much like a total goner and she probably just wanted to help Jack accept that.
Thank goodness he's so stubborn.

Icon from here

jlyn1980
God

According to Jay and Jack, I'm a god.

Posts: 1,943

help with kate Jul 26, 2009 21:23:07 GMT -5

Quote

Post by jlyn1980 on Jul 26, 2009 21:23:07 GMT -5

I agree with spinaltumor. When you are doing CPR in the middle of the jungle without the aid of a defibulator, it would be almost impossible to get a heart working again. And I think she just wanted him to stop, because to Kate, Charlie had already gone. And Jack was now just beating on him. Def one of the most powerful scenes I think Lost ever had.

"Jesus Christ is Lord, not a swear."-Colleen