get with it guys

[Joe in WinstonSalem]

Ok, I love your show.

It's better than all the other podcasts (except possibly one exception) because you sound like real people and it makes me feel that I am a part of something, even though I am just sitting at home by myself listening to day-old radio, basically. The only podcast that rivals yours is LOSTcasts, which is totally different in nature, and is more geared to figuring things out and combining theories and analyzing/scrutinizing everything than just having fun, which is where your podcast soars. That said, here's my problems with your show:

You guys are supposed to be hardcore fans, not wimpy fans. Everyone online and at other podcasts calls the hatch the hatchelor pad. Don't be so surprised by the word.

Also, anyone who listens to the official ABC podcast has known since November 28 (almost two and a half weeks ago) that Marvin Candle has a fake hand. The writers themselves explain it, and say the history of how he lost the hand will be revealed in an upcoming episode.

Also, I don't like the way you pronounce "picture" when you discuss the picture of Desmond and the girl. It's not a baseball pitcher or a pitcher of water, it's a PIC-TURE. Say it right next time. And I don't care where you were born or whether you have a southern accent or not. It's MON-ster.

Thanks! I've got space if you ever need to crash in Winston.

[Jack]

Joe said:

Ok, I love your show.

It's better than all the other podcasts (except possibly one exception) because you sound like real people and it makes me feel that I am a part of something, even though I am just sitting at home by myself listening to day-old radio, basically. The only podcast that rivals yours is LOSTcasts, which is totally different in nature, and is more geared to figuring things out and combining theories and analyzing/scrutinizing everything than just having fun, which is where your podcast soars. That said, here's my problems with your show:

You guys are supposed to be hardcore fans, not wimpy fans. Everyone online and at other podcasts calls the hatch the hatchelor pad. Don't be so surprised by the word.

Also, anyone who listens to the official ABC podcast has known since November 28 (almost two and a half weeks ago) that Marvin Candle has a fake hand. The writers themselves explain it, and say the history of how he lost the hand will be revealed in an upcoming episode.

Also, I don't like the way you pronounce "picture" when you discuss the picture of Desmond and the girl. It's not a baseball pitcher or a pitcher of water, it's a PIC-TURE. Say it right next time. And I don't care where you were born or whether you have a southern accent or not. It's MON-ster.

Thanks! I've got space if you ever need to crash in Winston.

I have to agree with you, we should have notice it before. I have to be honest, i've never listen to the ABC podcast, but I will start doing so.

As far as saying Munster & pitcher remember we're not the smart podcast. I think on the last show, I think we said monster.

Next time i'm in Winston Salem i'll take you up on your offer.

Thanks for listening

[heyes]

Now I feel dumb. I wish I listened to the official podcast, than I wouldn't be harping on something everyone already knew.

[Jack]

heyes said:

Now I feel dumb. I wish I listened to the official podcast, than I wouldn't be harping on something everyone already knew.

Thanks for getting us in trouble

[Jack]

OK I just listen to ABC Lost podcast. I'm stupid. I'm going to start listening to it, every week.

They did make a joke about Desmond running away because he thought the Island was going to blow up.
I think I made that joke first, but that's OK. It's there show

[heyes]

Well, you know, it's to be expected. They've been trying to mimick your style for too long now.

[dude]

dude, don't worry, the official podcast SUCKS!!! They try to be funny and aren't, and they subject us to mostly uninteresting chatter, while purposely avoiding topics of interest. And they make offhand comments that sometimes trivialize or belittle the fans, in my opinion. But they DO occasionally answer some questions and offer real nuggets of data by accident. They DO know the secrets, remember.

joe

[mutt]

you have to understand, joe
some of us are grownups ( dont hold that against us tho- we cant help it)
with yobs and rug rats and hired help to monitor
there is not alot of free time in Muttland
so I have to decide which podcast to listen to during that little tidbit of free time
now if I have to sit in a waiting room somewhere I DO listen to the ABC podcast
but otherwhys
its Jay and Jack
they make me smile

[Cliff]

Well first of all, I think that regardless of where it's been repeated, 'Hatchelor' is still really, really stupid. ;D


I don't expect Jay and Jack to know everything out there on other forums or podcasts - they ARE regular guys with regular lives and most of us don't have time to spend listening/reading everything. Like Mutt says, I have a child and a full-time job and I don't keep track (nor would I even want to) of all the miscellaneous theories and whatnot people have come up with. I simply don't care.

As for being hardcore fans, I've certainly never gotten that much of an impression from the show - it's funny and loose and not overly up its own butt with theorizing which is the main reason I like it. I tried listening to this one where they did nothing but talk about theories about this or that and after about 10 minutes of them droning on and on and on about it I gave up.

And as far as I'm concerned, they're grownups and can pronounce monster and picture any way they please.