Why do you hate Idol so much?

[bev]

After last nights show, all I can say is BLAKE wow!!!!!!!!!!!!! he was genius, I would buy that song yesterday.
I do think it'll be Phil and Chris tonight, ( no not you Casper, silly girl) I do agree that Melinda has the best voice on the show, she was awesome last night, but, I don't see her as an Am. Idol. I do see either Jordin or Blake as a winner, but feel that even if they didn't win on the show, that they'll still make it after the show, and I am sure that Melinda will also. Should be an interesting final.
What are your thought's Gracie Mom???

[Casper]

I think Kim must have had a field day with all the Bon Jovi songs and the man himself ...


I would guess Phil and Chris too ... but I think LaKisha's time is nearing its end as well.

When the show began with a quick strive past the contestants I thought: Who's that black haired midget?? ;D

[Colleen]

I can't say that I'm really an American Idol watcher (as you probably already know), but my grandparents are huge fans and my grandpa will make me watch Jordin & Melinda sing if I'm home...I saw Jordin sing "You'll Never Walk Alone" last week and it was really good, I must say. I like her, she's cute!

My grandma just said that she thinks Phil & Chris will be kicked off tonight, too.

[bev]

Well I did pick who would be in the final 3, I hope that either Jordin or Blake will win, as I have said before I love Melinda's voice I think she's awesome, I just don't think she fits as an American Idol. I guess we'll find out in a couple of weeks.

[Casper]

I like Blake okay but I thought he did not that much better than LaKisha this week. I think his routine gets a little old. If he does not improve significantly this week I see him as the next one to go ...

[bev]

Well look who's in the final 2, Blake and Jordin, my 2 favorite's. At this point I'd be happy with either one of them winning because I really like both of them. I still think that Melinda had the best voice all around, but just didn't think she looked like an American Idol. I really try to pick a person that I would like to see in person and that is not only a good singer but also a good entertainer, which I think that Blake is, and I would also buy his CD. when it comes out.
Just my thought's on the show, and Gracie's mom, I know who you're rooting for, good luck.
P.S. Did we ever make a bet on who'd win

[Kay]

I must admit I'm disappointed Melinda had to leave,...
I think Jordan is an awesome singer as well, but I still can't take Blake. I dunno.
He's just not someone who's music or singing I'd listen to in general.

I had hoped it'd be the girls in the finale. Well now I'm rooting for Jordan of course.

[Gracie's Mom]

Bev..
sorry I've missed all of these posts! The end of the school year is always nuts..because it's also Gracie's birthday month....but I've been keeping up with Idol.....I honestly wasn't thrilled with the Bon Jovi week...WHAT? I know!!! I loved seeing JBJ...yet...the contestants all annoyed me with the fact that they all picked the BIGGEST hits...which was not a great idea for them....Lakisha did the best that week because she picked a song not everyone knew...the others just couldn't do the songs justice *IMO* Melinda leaving was a shock...although I'm happy about it..she just isn't what you think of when you think AMERICAN IDOL...she was too old fashioned...and I think in the last couple of week...too sure of herself..she lost that "Golly Gee, I'm good?" thing and I think she had the contest in the bag....I do think Simon helped her get kicked off by saying..."I see MER-LINDA in the final" I think people then thought that they didn't need to vote for her so they voted for Jordin and Blake instead.

I've wanted Jordin to win since the very beginning...she is an amazing singer....but I think her personality is what will help her win...and plus...she is SO marketable to a broad audience...let's face it....after the third or fourth beat-box song...Blake's schtick gets O-L-D!

So I guess we'll find out this week....I'm callin' Jordin for the win!

[bev]

Good job on picking the winner Gracies Mom, man she really can sing and she's only 17 yrs. old, I loved Blake, I know he isn't the singer that she is, but he's a great entertainer, and as old as I am, I would love to see him in concert, but I will buy Jordins CD, when it comes out, well I'll buy his too. Either one could have won, and I wouldn't have been dissapointed at all, loved them both for different reasons.
Again Congrats. for picking this years winner

[PogsKlinc]

I loved both Blake and Jordin. I'm so glad that they'll both have great careers. (I'm listening to some Blake and Jordin music right now. ;D Check out their new EPs on iTunes. ;D )

I just want to come in and yell I hate Idol because THEY KICKED GINA OFF

old news i know, but I'm still mad over it

[eener]

Blake and Jordin's EP's are fantastic! I can see people hating, the show, but no one can hate them...well, a lot of people can, BUT I DON'T!!!